What is classical liberalism and in what ways is it different from modern American liberalism
Classical liberalism in another context is used to refer to forms of liberalism that occurred before twentieth century. It is an ideal term used to describe minimal government and economic freedom in America. Classical liberalism is used to mean early liberalism in America that focused on laissez-faire economics. Libertarians believe that classical liberalism is a form of governance in which the government is not in a position to provide social services to its citizens. The government in classical liberalism does not banking and industry sector. This was a common belief shared by American founding fathers. Classical liberalism includes belief in free markets, civil liberties, natural rights, individual freedoms, limited government, property rights and equality in law. The importance of classical liberalism was the idea of laissez-faire economic policy that benefitted the entire society. However, this policy did not prevent the state from providing basic public goods to its people. The term classical it is a contradiction of the recent 20th century concepts of liberalism (Huntington, 6). In addition, it relates to civil rights movement and modern liberalism.
Economic depression of late 19th century and early 20th century made classical liberalism to fall out of favor. This led to development of modern day classical liberals who had an objective in the welfare of the state. The individuals credited with revival of classical liberalism were faced by critics from their opponents who termed the process as neoliberalism. Classical liberalism share common practices with modern libertarianism and in certain instances the terms are used interchangeably. In other circumstances, a difference arises between classical liberalism and modern America liberalism.
Classical liberalism involves activities such as self interest, voluntary association and incentives that are not common in modern America liberalism. People in classical liberalism way of governance are bound by their own contracts, decisions and agreements. In this case classical liberals can engage in unpleasant jobs because they are entitled to their own decisions. Individual freedom is a common observation in classical liberalism that changed the way of doing things. Individuals recognize the rights of other individuals and have uncontracted obligations toward other people. Modern liberalism on the other hand contrasts the ideas of classical liberalism. Modern liberalism is the common or dominant political philosophy in America.
Modern liberalism in America also known as Welfare observes that every individual should have a guaranteed income. Modern liberals argue that the government has the responsibility to protect and safeguard the welfare of its citizens. Modern liberalism in America advocates for social obligations rather than basic rights. One common idea of modern liberalism in America is that individuals who are fortunate enough have the obligation to serve the entire community (Johnson, 10). The modern political philosophy in America has developed a system of state and public education that is used as a tool to shape responsible citizens.
Classical liberals argue that the idea of modern America liberalism to provide state education is mare propaganda and have been suspicious about the idea. This approach brings out differences between classical liberalism and modern America liberalism. Classical liberals believe that the right way to shape an individual is through family upbringing and participation of such individuals in ordinary institutions. On the other side, modern liberalism favors socialism which they belief is an important aspect of making individuals to realize their life agenda.
Classical liberalism favors incentives that help individuals to enroll in institutions of commercial society. Welfare liberalism has real problem with incentives and this gets problem on how individuals get things. Since the government is accountable for every need of the citizens, many individuals are not able to work on their own. Welfare recipients receive little incentives that force them to take unpleasant jobs and this is a major problem associated with modern liberalism. The political system in modern America has policies that government has the role to help its citizens through provision of basic commodities.
Individual freedom and right is a basic element in classical liberalism. As a matter of fact classical liberals believe that individual freedom should be treated as a moral right. In case of individual right, there has been disputes on the scope and character of these rights. According to classical liberalism provisions, the role of any existing government is to protect individuals rights. However, this is not a common practice by government in classical liberalism and this as per classical liberals is considered as the role of legitimate government. When individuals rights are safeguarded each citizen becomes happy and this promotes individuals welfare (Orem, 11). Individuals are considered as the best judges of their own judges and this idea contrasts provisions of modern liberalism.
Government should not intensively interfere with individuals consent and rights to life, property and liberty. On the other hand, modern liberalism in America is a combination of mixed economy, social liberalism and progressivism associated with Democratic Party. Individual freedom in modern America liberalism exists under the protection of a strong democratic elected government. The government is mandated to participate actively in society activities and development of economy. Provisions such as freedom or religion, voting rights, education and health as are provided for by modern liberalism is a clear indication that individual freedom is promoted in a free democratic government.
Classical liberals belief in rule of law other than rule of men whereby the w rule should be general, based son rational foundation, publicly available, capricious, not arbitrary, objective and not retrospective. Legitimate government is supposed to act on the basis of law but not as per prevailing circumstances. The law should be neutral as per individuals right on religion. Classical liberalism does not show emphasis on matters related to national defense and public goods. Modern liberalism agrees on protection of individuals right of life, liberty and happiness but this is not a common observation in classical liberalism (Dautrich, Yalof, 14).
Another area of disagreement is in the case of mail service or other basic necessities as are needed by individuals and can only be provided s by free market. Modern liberalism as was developed from liberal tradition aims at promoting the welfare of Americans and securing their liberty and prosperity. Modern libels believe in mixed economy in fear of improper wealth distribution and increased level of poverty. The reduction of poverty was a successful project of mixed economy since World War II. Americans belief that citizens have the right to enjoy basic commodities, protect environment and support equitable distribution of wealth.
Private property is another emphasis of classical liberalism whereby early classical liberals believed that individual rights include right to liberty, life and property. During the period of U.S declaration for independence, right to property was changed to something relevant in individuals life. Right to property was changed to right to pursuit of happiness. The main reason for making this change by classical liberals was that right to life, liberty and pursuit of happiness are considered as absolute rights while right to property is secondary. However, some classical liberals never agreed with these provisions and disputes arose among believers of classical liberalism. These differences among classical liberals are a strong aspect that means that traditional liberalism is a recognized political philosophy living in modern world.
This is supported by the presence of various practical and theoretical problems yet to be resolved. Private property should not be interfered with by other individuals, state and any other provisions outside the law. The law should safeguard private property acquired through proper means except in cases of emergency. During specified emergencies, the law should take wits due process to show the importance of individual property. The acquisition of private property should be in the right way so as the law to take its course. Any individual who confiscates the properly of another individual is considered as a trespasser and he or she should be dealt with accordingly (Johnson, 16). In modern liberalism, the government has the role to protect individual property. Every individual has the right to own property and use it in the right manner.
Development of classical liberalism
Three important figures are associated with development of early liberalism and these include John Locke, Adam Smith and John Stuart Mill. John Locke was a British political philosopher who emphasized on individual rights. He argued that the right of individual right and property is critical and should not be interfered with. John argued that individuals are in a position to acquire their own rights without the interference of government.
The sole purpose of government is to protect the rights of individuals on property and any government that does not recognize such rights should not be voted in. These views or ideas influenced colonists during time of America Revolution and are even instrumental in todays political philosophy. The idea of John Locke about the poor benefiting from surplus of the rich was instrumental in development of modern liberalism in America (Orem, 21). Welfare liberalism adopted this idea and many needy citizens have since benefitted from this idea.
Adam Smith a Scottish economist from 1723 to 1790 gives an account on individuals rights. He argues that individuals right is the basis for accumulation of wealth in a commercial society. Adam considers division of labor as one of the ways through which a legal government helps individuals to develop their own goals. Specialization of individuals in various tasks contributes to improved production. Another important development by Adam Smith is coordination of activities in a commercial society to improve production.
Adam argued that to get good results in a wider community a leader should be appointed to foresee the activities of other individuals. In a liberal society, peoples rights are respected and problem of coordination is resolved. These are the provisions of Adam Smith that has led to development of strong US market economy. According to Adam Smith, government should not be considered as the major source of individual right but individuals can develop their own means of protecting their well-being. He believed that wealth could be generated automatically and thus individual needs could be left to charity.
John Stuart Mill lived between 1806 and 1873. He was a British philosopher known for his contribution about individual liberty. Mills arguments on individual liberty were based on autonomy and self development. He claimed that if other people tolerated individuals liberty and freedom it would be a benefit to the entire society. According to Mill, toleration of diverse opinions is not easy but he argued that knowledge is fallible (Oerm, 27). The development of classical liberalism as per the three individuals is a true reflection of the political organizations in America. The ideas of the three thinkers led to development of modern classical liberalism. However, the three philosophers lacked metaphysical foundation that is necessary for classical liberalism.
Metaphysics is a philosophical term that is used to investigate reality that transcends science. John Locke was an Empiricist philosopher and Empiricism lacks rational metaphysics. This means that their ideas cannot provide strong foundation of politics. Adam Smith was not a strong supporter of metaphysics and thus his ideas did not provide support politics. Mill advocated for Utilitarianism a movement that provided little metaphysical foundations. Explicit metaphysical foundation is necessary for modern liberalism that is experienced in America. There is need for metaphysics among the provisions of the three philosophers.
Classical liberalism is a development in social and political environment in which the rights of human beings are protected. This happen where individuals are in an environment where they can judge their own interests, are bound by their own contracts, agreements and contracts. This contrasts the provisions of modern liberalism in America whereby the political environment does not allow individuals to engage in unjustifiable activities. The social aspect of modern liberal environment is a guided by certain provisions that ensure the government is responsible for its citizens social life. The government is supposed to provide health care, education and other social amenities to the people (Johnson, 41). This is a basic necessity and every individual in a modern liberal economy is entitled to such services.
Classical liberalism develops from political and social environment and it is possible to ground it on Classical Realistic metaphysics and realism. The metaphysics of man is the most basic element in the development of classical liberalism which is used to create happiness in human beings. Development of traditional liberalism to modern liberalism was an aspect of protecting individuals rights, liberty and right to property. Classical liberalism is a development in specific formulation that is essentially necessary for purpose of moral support.
Creation of wealth according to classical liberalism was a major area that raised conflicts with modern provisions. In modern American liberalism, creation of wealth is the role of government. The government is entitled to provide humble environment necessary for creation of wealth. The economy should be in a position to support individuals right of investment, owning property and creation of wealth. Political philosophy in modern America liberalism is a major factor that has contributed to a strong economy in the world.
Modern America liberalism supports adoption of scientific ideas such as global warming and evolution that does not exist in the ideas of conservatives. American modern liberals believe that they are open to change and subject to new ideas. While classical liberalism advocated for state ownership of basic means of production, modern liberalism support a political system in which leadership power is based on one democratic leader elected through voting (Dautrich, Yalof, 37).
American liberals believe that political freedom and opposition cannot be observed when power is vested in the state. The objective of modern liberalism is to create an environment that is conducive for economic development. This aims at regulating competition in business, create or establish good patterns of social security, supervise standards of life and labor. The ideology of modern American liberalism is a less aspect as compared to administrative and political development.
American ideals such as liberalism, democracy and equity are associated to political philosophy that led to increase in the level of production. Huntington argues that American politics are driven by class conflict and consensus theory. The classical or traditional liberalism provided that U.S had no conflict in class and is usually marked by consensus in the society. The strong political unity in American is due to democratic equality, liberty and authority. These ideals have been frustrated through hierarchies and institutions necessary to carry on essential functions of democratic society.
The ideals of democracy and power realities have led to political up heals. Americans in the modern American liberalism are working on strategies to reconstruct institutions so as to reflect national ideals. The objective of Huntingtons writings was to remove the disharmony between ideals on which America was founded and reality of government. He argues that in future tension between ideals and institutions will increase if a concrete solution is not found. The fate of liberty and democracy in America is linked to power in global affairs (Huntington, 16). These provisions are essential in support of sentiments as are provided to define classical liberalism.
A political creed in n mid 20th century provided a validity of impressionistic that was underscored by overwhelming evidence from poll data collected from public. The data provided that political creed of liberty, authority and equality were supported by 75 percent of the entire population. However, American creed is expressed in terms of support for majority rule, liberty, and religion, freedom of speech, democracy and minority rule. All these ideals receive massive support from American groups in modern liberalism. When the provisions of such values are made to support specific situations it becomes very difficult to create consensus in political philosophy.
The people who are in a position to support such ideals are the educated, individuals more active in politics and those who occupy high positions in organizations. Individuals with higher social economic status are in a good position of understanding the difference between ideals and institutions within a given political system. Classical liberalism promotes free trade and world peace between nations a view that is usually recognized as the modern development in American political system (Hintington, 23). Classical liberals aimed at abolishing royal charters and monopolies while modern liberalism aimed at encouraging entrepreneurship, increased productivity and promotion of democracy. Wealth of nations developed from wealth gatherers to industrial societies that have led to America reach its status of having a strong economy and super power nation.
0 comments:
Post a Comment